Colorblind modes
ACCESSIBILITY
Context
When I joined the project in 2019, I was tasked with being the design owner for accessibility on the production. This mandate involved building expertise in the field through extensive research, planning and design of accessibility features across various systems.
I quickly realized that there had been no prior accessibility expertise on the project and that certain established practices needed to be rethought.
In the following case study, I will detail some of the issues we encountered regarding the implementation of colorblind modes and explain how I rectified the situation.
MY ROLE
UX DESIGNER / ACCESSIBILITY OWNER
PROJECT
HYPER SCAPE (PC/CONSOLES)
STUDIO
UBISOFT MONTREAL
Color Blindness
Color blindness is a vision condition affecting color perception. It manifests as a difficulty in distinguishing certain hues when compared to the standard for normal human color vision—most commonly red and green or blue and yellow. It is often caused by the absence or dysfunction of specific photoreceptors (cones) in the retina.
Historically, the inclusion of colorblind modes in video games has often taken the form of corrective filters. In other words, the entire screen is tinted, without distinguishing between the user interface, visual effects and the environment. The problem with this approach is that while these filters simulate color blindness, but they do not necessarily address issues with contrast or readability.
Since color blindness is relatively rare and manifests in various forms, it is quite common for development teams to be oblivious to the fact that the solutions they have created are inadequate.
Tritanopia
No filters

Deuteranopia
example of corrective filters applied to the entire screen
Over time, it became possible to apply filters to specific elements only. This allows to target the user interface, for instance, and change its color to create better contrast with the background.
This is the approach that was initially used when I joined Hyper Scape.
Upon the game's release, we were surprised to find that an unusually large number of players were using the colorblind modes. Here is why that was problematic and how I addressed the issue.
Observations
The default mode's colors offered less contrast and visibility within the game environment compared to the colorblind modes. This was problematic because, in a competitive game where skill and reflexes significantly impact a player's chances of success, those who could identify enemies more easily or quickly held a considerable advantage.
Consequently, using colorblind modes to gain a competitive edge was unfair to players who did not use them. It was therefore natural for word to spread, and soon almost everyone was using the filters, even without being colorblind, proving the importance of good contrasts and how accessibility impacts everyone.
DEFAULT MODE



Enemies in proximity to the reticle have:
-
A red healthbar
-
A red outline
By default, the reticle is:
-
White
In ADS (Aim Down Sight), the reticle is:
-
Red
RESULT
-
Aiming in ADS reduces precision considerably, since the reticle is red on top of an outline of the same color.
PROTANOPIA MODE



-
A yellow healthbar
-
A red outline
-
White
-
Yellow
-
The yellow healthbar is more visible against the game environment, since it contains a lot a blue.
-
Aiming in ADS keeps a good readability.
TRITANOPIA MODE



-
A white healthbar
-
A red outline
-
White
-
White
-
The white healthbar is more visible against the game environment.
-
Aiming in ADS keeps a good readability.
Solutions
After observing these behaviors, we addressed the situation in several ways, given that the problem had multiple causes.
First, we tackled the accessibility issue, by keeping the reticle white at all times. It was unusual to see a reticle change color in aim down sight and having reduced ADS accuracy due to red-on-red contrast was undesirable. With this change, the default gameplay experience became much more accessible thanks to better contrast, and ADS accuracy was restored.
BEFORE

In ADS, the reticle changed to red
AFTER

In ADS, the reticle stays white
Next, we worked on the consistency issue. Initially, VFXs were not affected by the colorblind modes, but after continuing to work on the tech, we were finally able to affect the outlines as well. This way, regardless of the mode used, all players had consistent color across all feedback elements to represent enemies.
BEFORE
(PROTANOPIA)

With the colorblind modes, the outline stayed red and the healthbar changed color
AFTER
(PROTANOPIA)

With the colorblind modes, the outline and the healthbar both changed color
Lastly, thanks to a new technology relying on color palettes rather than filters, I completely overhauled the colors used in the colorblind modes. I ensured contrast was boosted where necessary while remaining faithful to the original colors.
This way, non-colorblind players could no longer exploit these modes to gain a significant competitive advantage, since the perceived difference between the colorblind modes and the default experience was minimal. Yet, for colorblind players, contrast was improved without compromising the art direction.
As perceived by a non-colorblind player
DEFAULT MODE
PROTANOPIA MODE


TRITANOPIA MODE

Now that the contrast issues with the default mode have been fixed, it remains ideal for non-colorblind players, as red is used solely to identify enemies and hazards
Although orange appear to offer higher contrast against some backgrounds, the environment itself already contains a great deal of orange, and therefore does not allow for a sufficiently fast reaction time
The color of the enemies is identical, so there is no added value for non-colorblind players to select this mode
As perceived by a protanopic player



Red isn't very contrasted for colorblind players, so it is preferable for them to use a colorblind mode instead
This mode is ideal for protanopic players, since they perceive orange as more contrasted (appears lighter)
The color of the enemies is identical, so there is no added value for non-colorblind players to select this mode
As perceived by tritanopic players


Red is very saturated for colorblind players, but one needs to consider how other colors are affected when selecting a colorblind mode
Orange is perceived as lighter by colorblind players, however it no longer stands out, as, yellows and oranges look alike and are already very prevalent in the game

Red is very saturated for colorblind players and considering how other colors are affected, this mode is ideal for them
The Impact
Following these changes, we observed a rate of colorblind mode usage that was much closer to the norm.
The default mode became the most widely used.
Learnings & Reflections
WHAT I LEARNED
-
How to properly implement colorblind modes (so as to correct the contract and readability issues)
-
How important it is to have a game accessible by design
-
To define the limits of how to develop accessibility in a competitive, multiplayer context
-
I built an expertise in accessibility and learned to be autonomous and confidently seize opportunities for development
WHAT I WOULD DO DIFFERENTLY
I received this mandate at the beginning of my career and despite my lack of experience, looking back, I wouldn't do anything differently.
It was an incredible learning experience and I'm proud of the way I threw myself into every challenge with the determination to prove myself. It enabled me to take on a key role regarding accessibility in my subsequent productions.
To prevent a similar situation from arising in the future, I now pay close attention to signs indicating that a system is not being used as intended, so that I can address the issue as early as possible. I also consider accessibility when designing the default game experience since, as this example highlights, accessibility issues can impact all players.
