Multi-Selection Interface
UX DESIGN
Context
This interface allowed players to customize an item before placing it in the world. It was accessible inside a central gameplay context, which already offered multiple complex interactions, like placement, rotation, etc.
The decision to pair two of the customization options together in the same interface could be explained by the way they worked in tandem.
As an example, imagine one is the shape of the item to place, while the other is its color. Both had an significant impact on the item to place and were subject to be changed simultaneously.
MY ROLE
UX DESIGNER
PROJECT
UNANNOUNCED (PC/CONSOLES)
STUDIO
UBISOFT MONTREAL
The Problem
How can players be made aware of all the customization options without causing cognitive overload?
Constraints
-
There are a lot of actions available at once for controller
-
Leadership insists the game must not feel like an editor
-
The quantity of content is subject to increase over time
-
There are opposite intents for customization
-
It must be quick
-
It must show as much content as possible
-

Item placement flow. The customization is in the framed area.
Initial Design
Two of the main references that inspired the initial design.

Hogwarts Legacy's item placement mode allows to toggle between color and item variants.

Enshrouded has building parts and materials customizable at the same time, with an on-demand menu to see more parts.
First Figma Prototype made to rapidly test the layout and navigation before creating the wireframes.
TRY IT OUT!
Use a Gamepad controller or click on the Dpad icons to customize the shape and color selections.


BY DEFAULT
-
The player can change shape by using Dpad Left/Right
-
The player can change color by using Dpad Up/Down
-
Visible quantity of options limited. Scrolling is supported
ON-DEMAND MENU
-
Holding RB shows more shapes
-
Navigation with the Dpad
-
Each row is a different category of shapes
-
Visible categories are limited to 3. Scrolling is supported
-
There aren't enough colors to require a similar interface
Cognitive Walkthrough, used to identify potential usability issues
MAIN GOAL THE USER WANTS TO CUSTOMIZE THEIR SHAPE AND COLOR SELECTIONS
TASK 01 CHANGE SHAPE
Correct Action
Press Dpad Left or Right
Will the user know what to do at this step?
Yes
Why?
The shape list is visible with the controls on each side
Will the user know they did the right thing?
Yes
Why?
Pressing the inputs changes the selection on the UI and 3D preview
TASK 02 CHANGE COLOR
Press Dpad Up or Down
Yes
The color list is visible with the controls above and below
Yes
Pressing the inputs changes the selection on the UI and 3D preview
STRENGTHS
-
Navigation: Navigating the two lists with separate axis works well
PAIN POINTS
-
Input mapping: Natural mapping cannot be applied to gameplay actions that would benefit from it, since Dpad is used for UI navigation
-
Uniformity: Categories don't have the same amount of content
-
Scalability: The interface doesn't support long term needs
The initial design had no significant usability issue and it offered a natural mapping for the UI navigation. It worked well because each selection could be navigated and were represented visually as two different axis. On the other hand, scalability of the interface was becoming an issue because we kept adding more content. While this design worked well for some competitors, we simply had too much content for it to be a viable solution.
Also, the user tests revealed players were often using the same shapes and colors. So for the next iteration, I wanted to move the customization a level deeper, to free some inputs and allow users to find content more easily.
First Iteration




ON-DEMAND (QUICK) MENU
-
Pressing RB opens up a menu to customize both Shape and Color
-
The player can change Shape by navigating a Vertical List on the left side
-
The player can change Color by navigating a Vertical List on the right side
-
The player can navigate between Shape and Color with Left/Right inputs
-
Both lists are scrollable and ordered by recent use
FULL CATALOG
-
Press X while in the Quick Menu to see a full catalog
-
Items are ordered by categories
-
Shapes and Colors are separated in different tabs
-
Both lists are scrollable and support addition of content
Cognitive Walkthrough, used to identify potential usability issues
MAIN GOAL THE USER WANTS TO CUSTOMIZE THEIR SHAPE AND COLOR SELECTIONS
TASK 01 OPEN THE CUSTOMIZATION MENU
Correct Action
Press RB
Will the user know what to do at this step?
Yes
Why?
The input is visible on the previous screen
Will the user know they did the right thing?
Yes
Why?
The interface changes
TASK 02 CHANGE SHAPE
Press Dpad Down
No
The visual representation can be mistaken for a radial selection with the joystick
Yes
Pressing the inputs changes the selection on the UI and 3D preview
TASK 03 CHANGE COLOR
Press Dpad Right, then Dpad Down
No
Users sometimes press A to confirm the shape selection before attempting to change the color, which closes the menu
No
The difference is very subtle when the focus in on the shape VS. color
TASK 04 CLOSE THE MENU
Press A or B
Yes
The control reminders are displayed on the bottom of the screen
Yes
Pressing the input closes the menu instantly
IMPROVEMENTS
-
Intuitiveness: Removing UI navigation allowed us to use natural input mapping for gameplay actions
-
Content: Faster to find something, as more options are displayed in the Catalog
PAIN POINTS
-
Usability: Navigation between the two lists is too error prone
-
Intentionality: Pressing A confirms both selections and closes the menu
-
Exposition: The Catalog is hard to access. Some players don't know it exists
With this version, we successfully gained more leeway for the gameplay controls, by removing the UI navigation (4 inputs). I also tried a different approach of keeping Shape and Color in the same interface, but it didn't pay off as I had hoped. Instead, it confirmed I successfully had created a multi-selection interface with the initial design, through the mapping on different axis. Additionally, the user tests revealed I needed to reduce the risk of making mistakes and increase intentionality, so that was my focus for the next iteration.
Second Iteration

SHAPE CATALOG
-
Press X to open the Shape Catalog
-
Navigation with Dpad Left/Right or Left Stick (like any menu)
-
Press A to confirm selection
-
Added features to support a better categorization and addition of content:
-
Categories
-
Filters
-
Sorting options
-
Favorite system
-

COLOR CUSTOMIZATION
-
Press Y to open the Color customization UI
-
Navigation with Dpad Left/Right
-
Press A to confirm selection
Cognitive Walkthrough, used to identify potential usability issues
MAIN GOAL THE USER WANTS TO CUSTOMIZE THEIR SHAPE AND COLOR SELECTIONS
TASK 01 OPEN THE CUSTOMIZATION MENU
Correct Action
Will the user know what to do at this step?
Why?
Will the user know they did the right thing?
Why?
Press Y
Yes
The input is visible on the previous screen, next to the current shape
Yes
A menu will open with a camera transition
TASK 02 CHANGE SHAPE
Use Dpad or Left Joystick
Yes
The navigation follows the same logic as any other menu in the game
Yes
Pressing the inputs changes the selection on the UI and 3D preview
TASK 03 CONFIRM SELECTION / CLOSE THE MENU
Press A or B
Yes
The control reminders are displayed on the bottom of the screen
Yes
The menu closes as soon as either inputs are pressed. The shape is equipped after pressing A or reverted after pressing B
TASK 04 OPEN THE COLOR CUSTOMIZATION MENU
Press X
Yes
The input is visible on the previous screen, next to the current color
Yes
The interface changes
TASK 05 CHANGE COLOR
Use Dpad Left or Right
Yes
The controls are visible on each side of the list
Yes
Pressing the inputs changes the selection on the UI and 3D preview
TASK 06 CONFIRM SELECTION / CLOSE THE MENU
Press A or B
Yes
The control reminders are displayed on the bottom of the screen
Yes
The menu closes as soon as either inputs are pressed. The color is equipped after pressing A or reverted after pressing B
IMPROVEMENTS
-
Intentionality: The players open the desired interface through separate inputs
-
Usability: No more navigation error. The player doesn't affect the wrong customization by mistake
In the end, we ended up separating the customization of Shape and Color in two distinct interfaces, with their respective access. Not because multi-selection interfaces are not viable, but because in this case, the content and users had different needs. It took us multiple iterations and user tests to understand that our pre-conceived idea of how players would interact with the content was wrong. It's only once we switched to a full user-centric approach that we started seeing meaningful results.
The Problem
How can players be made aware of all the customization options without causing cognitive overload?
The Answers
EXPOSURE
Players can't know something exists if it's not noticeable or accessible when needed
SCALABLE SOLUTIONS
Using filters, sorting, favorite system, search function, etc.
SIMPLIFICATION
Using natural mapping and separating the information to facilitate decision making
Learnings & Reflections
WHAT I LEARNED
-
Testing an idea is always worth it, because it can highlight issues otherwise invisible on paper
-
We never fully know what players will think or how they will interact with our designs until we've seen it in user tests
-
Resilience is key. Designs evolve and we need to be open to change
-
Coming back to an older design is not necessarily a failure, it can mean something was learned
WHAT I WOULD DO DIFFERENTLY
Our initial intention to offer a single interface for the selection of two different elements ended up quite a challenge, but it allowed me to test different approaches, take calculated risks and get some learnings.
In this specific case, if I could do things differently, I would collect user feedback earlier to understand how they interact with the game. Had we done it sooner, we could have observed that it was totally fine to separate the two customization options.
